19 June 2018

In Spite of Lions by Scarlette Pike

Shortlisted for book of the month


AMAZON UK £5.25 £12.69
AMAZON US $7.53 $12.63
AMAZON CA $8.93

Family drama / adventure
19th century
London & Africa

Anna is running away. From whom or what? She has changed her name and takes passage on a ship bound for anywhere. She doesn’t care, doesn’t even want to know. She is determined to shed the constraints of her society and live independently somewhere far away from England. The captain of the ship turns out to be a man from her past, the husband of a late and dear friend. He too has changed his name. Why? He is a very menacing and mysterious character and Anna is wary of him. Could he possibly be the love interest? To add a little more spice to the pot, also on the ship are Mrs. David Livingstone and children who are going to meet Mr. Livingstone. Yes, Anna’s destination turns out to be Africa.

By this time – the third chapter – I was so firmly hooked, I could hardly move from my chair. Nothing could be a greater contrast to Anna’s previous experience than the lifestyle of the Livingstones and the culture of Africa. We observe this young, well-bred English lady as she rides for days in the back of a wagon, watches an animal being butchered, learns to pluck a fowl, lives through a drought, a lion attack and a war… and yet loves Africa. Meanwhile she suffers nightmares of her past life and struggles to come to terms with the person she was.

Anna is a bit of a trope – a woman trying to live according to the mores of a later time – but because of the author’s excellent writing and story-telling, she rises above such clichés. All the main characters are interesting and well-presented, but my favourite is the Chief - also a real person - as colourful and delightful a character as you could hope to meet. The relationship between him and the Livingstones is heartwarming.

Judging by the ending, I feel sure there will be another book.
Heartily recommended

© Susan Appleyard

<previous   next >

click here to return to home page 'Bookshelf' then scroll down for more items of interest

18 June 2018

Swords of the King by Charlene Newcomb

shortlisted for Book of the Month

AMAZON UK £3.51
AMAZON US $5.00
AMAZON CA $6.28

Battle Scars : Book 3

Fictional saga / LGBT

1200s
Crusades

This is the third book in Ms Newcomb’s series featuring Henry de Grey and Stephan d’Aigle, two men bound to serve their king, Richard I of England. In the previous books we’ve travelled with our knights to the Holy Land, held our breath as they’ve done their best to safeguard the realm of England against Prince John’s attempts to usurp the throne, and now we are in the year of Our Lord 1196, in France.

Richard has returned to his realms substantially changed after his time as a captive. Throughout the book, Ms Newcomb manages to convey that the king is living his life in the fast lane, as if determined to outrun fate. Is Richard aware that time is running out? Not really. It is more that his experiences have left him so filled with hatred for some of his former allies—Philippe Augustus of France being one of them—that his to-do list has grown unmanageable. Richard wants revenge. He wants to rub the Capetian king’s nose in the dirt. He wants to shore up the Angevin empire, he needs to do something about Flanders and the Bretons, and, of course, there’s the knotty issue of the succession—and of Richard’s dear brother, John.

Ms Newcomb does an excellent job not only or presenting this convoluted political landscape, but also of adding the human dimension. Richard is generous to those he trusts and sufficiently self-confident to extend the benefit of the doubt to his younger brother. John, on the other hand, is simply biding his time. Richard’s mother despairs at ever getting her favourite son to spend sufficient time with his queen to sire that much-needed heir. Richard’s former sister-in-law, Constance of Brittany, trusts no Angevin further than she can throw them—rightly so, seeing as she has a young son, Arthur, to look out for.

However, despite all this fascinating history, it is Henry and Stephan who star in this novel. Mostly told through Henry’s POV, we yet again get a sensation of time running out. Both Henry and Stephan are fully aware that they’ve made an enemy for life out of John and as their king seems disinclined to put in the effort required to bring forth the pitter-patter of little feet, they are now starting to realise John may well become their next king. God help them then…

It isn’t only Henry and Stephan who walk in fear of John. Their good friend Robin (a rather delightful and creative version of the Robin Hood of legends) is equally affected. This fear seeps into their everyday life, it colours their thoughts and affects their decisions. Most elegantly, Ms Newcomb thereby makes John, who is rarely present, a central character in the story. The shadow he casts taints everything in Henry’s and Stephan’s life.

It doesn’t help that Henry and Stephan share more than the friendship one would expect between two men who have repeatedly faced death together. They are also lovers, thereby made doubly vulnerable. However, despite their fears, despite the growing sense of premonition, it is through their love that Henry and Stephan find solace. As in the previous books, Ms Newcomb manages to convey both passion and intimacy between her two knights. This time round, their relationship is threatened by expectations: the king demands that Henry marry and Henry can do little but acquiesce. How all this ends and how it affects Stephan and Henry I leave for the reader to discover for themselves.

Swords of the King ends on a sad note. It can do no other as Ms Newcomb is bound by the historical facts. I dare say only one man rejoices at the turn of events in 1199, and that man’s name is John…

I hope to meet Henry and Stephan again. I hope to see what life they make for themselves in an England ruled by their very own personal nemesis, King John. Until then, I can but doff my cap and thank Ms Newcomb for having introduced me to this vividly depicted world of Richard Lionheart, his mother and his loyal knights.

© Anna Belfrage


click here to return to home page 'Bookshelf' then scroll down for more items of interest

16 June 2018

The Weekend (at last!) 16th June

No reviews over the weekend 
but did you miss...


* * *
Have you seen our

where you will find all sorts of interesting things
 to amuse, entertain and inform!


15 June 2018

The June mid-month extra: The Genesis of a Novel with Christy Nicholas



The Genesis of a Novel
by Christy Nicholas

Christy
This below is from a series of posts I’ve been writing, following the process of producing a novel from conception through publication and beyond. I began this series in July, 2016. Although I’ve already started on the process, I thought it might be interesting to blog my way through the novel creation process. I’m already through about the first three-four days’ worth of work, so those will be schmooshed into this post.
I’m working on the fourth novel in the Druid’s Brooch series. Book 1, Legacy of Hunger is already published, Book 2 was just published in January 2017 (Legacy of Truth), and book 3 is submitted to my publisher and due out soon (Legacy of Luck). 

Legacy of Hunger: Druid's Brooch Series: #1

Legacy of Truth: Druid's Brooch Series: #2


Legacy of Luck: Druid's Brooch Series: #3

The idea will be to have three trilogies in total. The first trilogy (the Legacy books) will be in the 18th/19th century. The second trilogy (the Misfortune books) will be in the 11th/12th century. The third and final trilogy (the Age books) will be in the 5th/6th century, and the final book of that trilogy will give the origins of the brooch itself.

So, that means in order to plan my next book, I really have to plan out SIX novels. And make them all tie neatly into a bow at the end. Right. OK, deep breath, let it out easily. Let’s do this.

Most writers are Planners or Plotters to some extent. I’m pretty strong on the Planner end of the spectrum. That means I like to plan out my book and my scenes, flesh out my characters and my subplots before the first word is written. Yes, it can change later due to the capriciousness of my muse and my own editing, but that’s how I begin. I use something called The Snowflake Method which has been a Gods’ Send to this AR accountant with aspirations of authorship.

FIRST: The Concept
My first job was to come up with a basic premise for each book. A once-sentence elevator pitch. Something like ‘1940s nurse travels back in time 200 years and falls in love with a Highlander in the Jacobite revolution’ would be for Outlander. Each basic plot should have a conflict, a main character, and a resolution. For my series, each has to connect in some way to the others in the trilogy. The main character in one might be the grandfather in the next one, or the great-granddaughter of the previous one. Then try to mix it up – make sure you aren’t reusing basic plot devices, character types, even different ages.

For book 4, which has the working title of Misfortune of Vision, my main plot is a quest for an heir, and my main character is a 65-year-old grandmother. Because we need more adventure books with experienced heroes! Sure, I won’t be able to write in as much angst and rebellion, but I can get in plenty of snark and sarcasm. And I love it when little old ladies order everyone else around.

I made sure the main elevator-pitch plot was done on the other five books-to-be, so I had a good variety of themes and plots, and so I didn’t run out of ideas and have to change something I’d already done. 

SECOND: The Synopsis
Now, this little old lady needs a quest – so she’s going to seek out her grandson. Why? Well, she has this heirloom, you see. A magic brooch she must gift to a relative. And her children are all dead. Why? Well, you might have to read the book to find out.

I want to find a time of great conflict to set the book in. External conflict is easier to meld into the characters’ conflict, adding tension and action. Of course, when I decided on 12th century Ireland, I had NO idea exactly how violent this time was in the northeast of Ireland. I knew it was bad in the southeast with the Norman invasion, but this time period makes Game of Thrones look like a peaceful Sunday picnic. The main historically reliable documents from the time mostly just list the deaths of kings and nobles, bishops, and the like. And there were a lot of them! It seemed like every minor king had a relative who hated him enough to off him for his throne.

Mix in: The Research
Then I lost myself in research. I dropped down into a rabbit hole of the Annals of Irish History, CELT, Lady Gregory, Yeats, and the ever-mocking Wikipedia. I researched kings and social structure. I researched clergy and local saints. I looked up fairy queens and holy wells. I delved into Neolithic mounds and burnt villages. After a good 15 hours’ worth of research, I checked out the local Vikings (called Ostmen at the time, or simply Foreigners), the Normans, and the Irish. I discovered that there was a local king who was a bit of a craven coward. He just fled when the Normans arrived.

Cool! Cowardly kings are great! Let’s use him.  Now I know where my main character lives, she has a purpose, plenty of crap to get in her way. I’ve added some characters to make her life even more difficult. I made that one sentence elevator pitch into a paragraph, and then into three paragraphs. Those three paragraphs have now become two full pages of detailed plot synopsis. Whew!!

Now I have to take a break. My head is swimming with possibilities, and the scenes are already beginning to form in my head. No! Not yet! Back, back you fools! You’re not on cue yet. I need my characters first.

THIRD: The Characters
The main character is always the toughest. They set the theme for the whole book. I have a bad tendency to polarize my characters, especially the female leads. They are either contrary and sniping or they are passive and weak. I’m definitely going with the former for Grandma here, but I hope to make her kind as well. But with a nasty temper and a tendency to rap people hard with her walking stick. Because why not?

I fill in her physical characteristics, her hobbies, her quirks. Everyone must have virtues and vices. Tics and habits. Catch phrases, favorite curses, anything to humanize her. Does she like cloud-watching? Play with her hair? Yell ‘Gadzooks!’ whenever she meets someone new?

Now do this with the rest of your characters. You should have a good collection of people from your synopsis at this point. I’ve got a dozen already – Irish, Normans, Norsemen, and some Fae. Set up conflict. Make some inflexible, some easy-going. Don’t go for the obvious. Make the churchman the easy-going one and the Fool the guy with a stick up his butt. Mix it up. Remember, everyone has flaws and everyone has good points. No one is a perfect villain or a perfect hero. Make sure each of your characters has motivations, and for the bigger ones, good story arcs and growth within the story.

Now, it’s time to let things percolate. I’m going back to editing my other manuscript, and let the synopsis, characters and scenes percolate in my brain while my palate clears...

Next The Scene List
The Genesis of a Novel – Research 
The process of writing a novel is a scary mystery to most people. Sometimes including those that actually write novels! My own process is just one of thousands of processes, but here is a peek into my mad method.

As I’ve delayed the next step – actually writing out my scene list – in favor of editing a previous manuscript, I’ve given my unconscious mind some time to percolate the story. I’ve worked out a few additional conflicts to add to my 2-page synopsis. I’ve combined a couple of the conflicts so they mesh together a bit better. I’ve done lots of additional research on the time period (12th century Ireland), and realized that I’ve actually read several books set in that time period by authors whose research I respect.  Ken Follett (Pillars of the Earth), Sir Walter Scott (Ivanhoe), and Ellis Peters (Brother Cadfael Mysteries) have written in that time period. That gives me some ‘flavor’ of the setting and how people lived.

For some people, anything prior to modern times is ‘ancient’ and there is little differentiation between those periods. For an historian, however, or an enthusiast of historical fiction, those differences are important. For instance, a noblewoman of 17th century France would wear a completely different costume than a noblewoman in 12th century France: note the images! 





And they are VERY different from a 21st century French noblewoman.



When writing details of the time period, an author could research the different foods a character is eating (Pro tip: McDonald’s wasn’t period!), clothing, the way they made their living, etc.

Speech and idiom is the hardest part. It’s a balancing act. Of course the 12th Century Irish character isn’t speaking anything resembling English. They aren’t even speaking modern Irish. They’re speaking Middle Irish, and no one today outside of a few scholars would easily be able to read it. I certainly wouldn’t be able to write it. Even if it was in England, 12th century language is very different from today’s. If you doubt me, go read some Anglo-Norman works. English as a language didn’t exist – it was a proto-mix of German from the Anglo-Saxon peasants and French from the Norman nobles.

So we use mostly modern English in historical novels. But we can’t use pure modern English, as that would sound strange. Telling someone that the assassin was going to ‘pop a cap’ in his victim’s head just seems… wrong.

Most historical fiction authors sprinkle older words and phrases into modern English and try to limit the anachronisms to give a ‘flavor’ of the time. Sometimes this is easy – often it isn’t. It involves a lot of research, delving into resources such as Etymonline and historical theses.

Once you have written in a particular time period, of course, you get a feel for the language. You can just add a couple or words or phrases to your characters’ lexicon and the reader is transported to their time and place. Well, if you’ve done it well, that is.

There is always a danger of putting in TOO much flavor. Have you ever had a dish that was so heavily spiced that all you tasted was the seasoning, and not the food itself? Some writing ends up like that. Where you have to sound out the words on the page to make any sense of what was being said. I’ve seen some too-accurate Glasgow accents written this way. Or Cockney. Or deep south American. Just remember – less is more! And please don’t use phrases like “Avast ye, knavish varlet!”

Swearing is an area that is particularly difficult. A modern person swears differently than someone in the 18th century, 16th century, or the 5th century would. In the past, most swearing was religious in nature – ‘Zounds’, used liberally by Shakespeare, was short for ‘God’s Wounds’. Now, in a society less dominated by religion, we use words more related to physical body functions!

These are little things that must be kept in mind as you are writing your manuscript. Little but important. A glaring anachronism can push a reader right out of the story, and their suspense of disbelief shattered. Often small discrepancies can be forgiven (like rose madder being used to dye cloth in the 12th century when it didn’t become popular until the 13th). These are details only a historian or pedant will care about. Others, not so much (like horned helmets on Vikings). Don’t make your 12th century character a Baptist.

The Genesis of a Novel – Place
Location, location, location

Where do you write?
They say to ‘write what you know.’ Now, if that were entirely true, there would be no such thing as speculative fiction, science fiction or fantasy. However, to some extent it does hold true. Writing about a place you are intimately familiar with can help with details.
I mostly write about Ireland. Do I live there? No. But my ancestors did. Well, some of them. 11% of them, according to my DNA test! 

But I have visited many times, and Ireland holds a piece of my soul. I have visited every county in Ireland, albeit some only briefly. I love putting details in my writing from the places I’ve been, and it helps to add verisimilitude to the story. Now, most of my books are set in historical time periods, so I do research to see what was actually there at the time. The grand cathedral in the center of the market town may have been built in 1848, and your book is set in 1846, so maybe you have a construction site, but no finished building. These sort of details are important to me.

But how do you find such details? Sometimes it’s difficult to research the history of places. Buildings such as churches can be somewhat easier, as there are good records as to church building. You may have to dig a little, but usually the Catholic church keeps good track of such things. And if you go early enough, no buildings are on record. For instance, I was working on a novel called The Enchanted Swans, which starts in 500 BCE. No churches in Ireland then! Of course, there were lots of buildings – roundhouses and crannogs. But none were made of stone, all wood palisades. 

But landscape doesn’t change much over time. Sure, bits of cliff may fall into the ocean, or mountain tops are leveled for a tourist view, but for the most part, Conor’s Pass in Dingle offers a similar view to what it’s had for a thousand years. And having been to that view – three times before I could see anything due to heavy mists! – I can describe what there is in a novel.

No matter where your imagination takes you, make sure to know the place well before you try to transport others there. Even if it’s only research via old photographs, paintings, or Google Earth, there is a way to make sure the details come through and become part of your story.

About Christy Nicholas

Christy Nicholas, also known as Green Dragon, is an author, artist and accountant. After she failed to become an airline pilot, she quit her ceaseless pursuit of careers that begin with ‘A’, and decided to concentrate on her writing. Since she has Project Completion Disorder, she is one of the few authors she knows with NO unfinished novels.

Christy has her hands in many crafts, including digital art, beaded jewelry, writing, and photography. In real life, she’s a CPA, but having grown up with art all around her (her mother, grandmother and great-grandmother are/were all artists), it sort of infected her, as it were.


She wants to expose the incredible beauty in this world, hidden beneath the everyday grime of familiarity and habit, and share it with others. She uses characters out of time and places infused with magic and myth.



Combine this love of beauty with a bit of financial sense and you get an art business. She does local art and craft shows, as well as sending her art to various science fiction conventions throughout the country and abroad.



Links:


we have already reviewed some of Christy's books here on Discovering Diamonds (more reviews coming soon!)
The Enchanted Swans (selected as Cover of the Month) 


< previous Mid-Month Extra .... Next >

14 June 2018

A Discovering Diamonds review of Field Of Dust by Angela Jean Young


 AMAZON UK £3.99 £8.46
AMAZON US $5.62 $13.54 
AMAZON CA $6.77 $16.94

Biographical fiction / Family drama
Victorian

Flossie is a young girl waiting for her mother to tumble out of the local hostelry when she witnesses the sinking of the Princess Alice at Northfleet, where the Grant family lives. Samuel Grant works in one of the local cement factories and Mary, Flossie's mother, takes in washing to supplement her dependence on gin. Flossie has a younger sister, Lottie. Thus we have a background of one family amongst many others suffering in the poverty of the Victorian age.

The author paints a vivid picture of life in the North Kent slums and some of the characters that populated them. She is also able to include some memorable happenings – from Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show to Jack the Ripper – as well as an insight into the newly founded homes of Dr Barnado where the girls are taken by their mother when she abandons them to return to her native Ipswich. Devastated by this action and confused that their mother handed them over with a different surname, Flossie is determined to find the truth about why their mother left – the more so when Lottie is sent to Canada by the Barnado's authorities. Slowly, as she grows up, she finds the terrible truth about both her mother and father and a face from the past suddenly reappears.

This is an interesting read and has an easy pace, to it but for me I felt that there was some ‘telling’ and not enough ‘showing’ in the narrative, especially in the first ‘scene setting’  chapters where little happens until the girls are deposited at Dr Barnado's. Nevertheless, I can recommend this book to anyone interested in Family History and/or the plight of poor families in the Victorian slums, as the research seems good, and the historical aspect is intriguing.

© Richard Tearle


click here to return to home page 'Bookshelf' then scroll down for more items of interest

13 June 2018

Seraphina's Song by Kathryn Gauci

shortlisted for Book of the Month


AMAZON UK £2.98 £8.60
AMAZON US $4.18 $11.00
AMAZON CA $5.13 $13.84

family drama
1930s 
Greece

How is it I hear you say, that Dionysos Mavroulis, son of Haralambos and the saintly Maroulia, God rest their souls, ended his days dead on a rubbish dump near Pasalimani with his throat cut? That, my dear reader, is the question I have often asked myself. If you will spare me a little of your time I will share with you my story so that others might learn from such a fate.” So opens Kathryn Gauci’s new novel. This time she takes us to Piraeus in Greece in the 1930s. A time when Greece was a desperately poor nation, but Dionysos Mavroulis, a refugee from Asia Minor, has even less. Plagued by the guilt of his own survival and the loss of his parents and future wife, Dionysos spends his time in hashish dens bent on self-destruction until an unlikely benefactor takes him under his wing and gives him hope for a far, far brighter future. The trouble is, we know from the opening lines that the hero of this story is going to end up dead on a rubbish heap.

Dionysos is a man without a future; a man who embraces destiny and risks everything for love. He escapes Smyrna in 1922 disguised as an old woman. Alienated and plagued by feelings of remorse, he spirals into poverty and hitting rock bottom, he meets Aleko, an accomplished bouzouki player. Recognising in the impoverished refugee a rare musical talent, Aleko offers to teach him the bouzouki. Dionysos’ hope for a better life is further fuelled when he meets Seraphina — the singer with the voice of a nightingale. “If I knew then, dear reader, what I know now, I should have turned on my heels and left. But no, instead, I stood there transfixed on the beautiful image of Seraphina. In that moment my fate was sealed.”

Told in the first person by a well-educated young man born into a prosperous merchant family but forced from his home with only the clothes on his back, we see Dionysos grasp at a chance to escape aimlessness and poverty. His benefactor, Aleko, watches him dance in a tavern and recognises his rare intuition for music and rhythm. This then opens a world of new experience for Dionysos, but it is also his introduction to the grubby underworld of Papazoglou, local mob boss and tavern owner, and where he meets Seraphina, who will be his downfall. What we do not know - and I shall not say because it would spoil the story – is why Aleko and his wife foster Dionysos for no obvious gain. Their motive, however, is the key to the plot, and in part to the fate of the lovers.

Gauci creates in this novel the smoke, songs and music of Papazoglou’s tavern so convincingly one can almost hear the strings through the tobacco-fuelled murk. It is also like watching a 1940s cine noir movie. At times I was reminded of Oran Pamuk’s novels, but mostly the film versions of Raymond Chandler stories, perhaps because we know our modest hero is fated thanks to a stunningly beautiful woman. Seraphina is a classic femme fatal: a woman gifted with a hypnotic voice and haunting beauty, both worldly and yet vulnerable, and at the mercy of the ruthless, despicable Papazoglou. Cine noir meets Greek tragedy – a tragedy played out with depression era realism.

My only misgiving about this book is that as a reader I wasn't able to hope for a happy outcome: Dionysos’ refusal to face facts and his lack of deviousness means that what is going to happen is just a little too obvious – although the lovers so very nearly made it. Nevertheless, this is definitely a Discovered Diamond.

© J.G. Harlond
ARC copy reviewed

click here to return to home page 'Bookshelf' then scroll down for more items of interest


12 June 2018

A Discovering Diamonds review of Daughter of War by S J A Turney


AMAZON UK £2.99 £8.99
AMAZON US $4.19 $13.99
AMAZON CA $4.99 $17.58

Book 1

Military / Fictional Saga
Knights Templar  / 1200s
Spain

Don't trust the cover art, that is the most important piece of advice I can give you, because if you think this is a story of the warrior girl on the cover, you'll be disappointed.

Arnau Vallbona is introduced to us as a young knight fighting against the Almohad of Spain in the company of a Templar knight who leaves a deep impression on him. The battle is won but there are losses, losses that change the course of Arnau's life.

Despite the sweeping saga promised by the preface, this is a more contained piece, detailing events that occur for the majority over a week and in the space of a couple of square miles. This is one of the strengths of the novel, the ability to make a small community of Templars interesting, concentrating on a handful of characters who never roam far. The detail of the Templar life is quite astonishing, the minutiae of being a knight and the trappings of knighthood are a joy to discover, if you are of that mind, and the brutality is laid bare of what a sword or mace is going to do in battle in a manner rarely seen in most historical fiction, bringing a layer of understanding to the genre.

However, there are a few drawbacks, the cover art being the greatest. It is misleading at best. The title may be 'Daughter of War' but the cover image on the copy I read was of a character who never appears in the book. A case of a traditional publishing house marketing department not having a clue what the book is actually about. There were a few typos, I'll forgive those as this was a review copy, but there were also a few slips in the research, language being another major one for me, more obvious as I have spent significant time in Catalunya where the novel is set.

But negatives aside, this is a good novel with a believable, consistent storyline that ends as well as it can. Any fan of military history and knights will thoroughly enjoy this.

© Nicky Galliers



click here to return to home page 'Bookshelf' then scroll down for more items of interest


11 June 2018

A Discovering Diamonds review of Jan by Peter Haden

AMAZON UK £3.99 £4.51
AMAZON US $5.62 $13.87

Biographical fiction
1940s / World War II
Germany. Poland and England

Jan Janicki, a young Polish lad and son of a farmer, is sent to a near neighbour, Gunther Raschdorf, a German, as an apprentice to be an engineer. They become friends and watch in horror as war becomes inevitable. Gunther reveals that his wife is half Jewish and that their daughter, Renate, is classed as Mischling. Gunther entreaties Jan to escort Renate far away to a place of safety. Jan then continues into Belgium with the intention of making his way to England to join the armed forces. But the authorities see something else in Jan and he is offered the chance to return to Poland as an undercover liaison between England and the Polish resistance. Once his cover is blown, Jan has to escape with his brother and his girlfriend.

This is a good read, based on the true story of the author's uncle, and has lots of action, but I have a few, I hope constructive, criticisms. Vital as he is to the story, I felt Gunther's life in the German army during the first world was overlong and a bit intrusive as it takes up the first few chapters, leaving me wondering just who I was reading about. Much of this backstory, I felt, could have been introduced bit by bit during conversations or reflections. I noticed, too, that the author used the services of a translator – which is laudable. It may be a personal thing, but I prefer to be gently reminded every so often that the characters are not speaking in English, but here I found the instances of both Polish and German just a few too many for my taste as it interrupted the flow of the narrative. There were also some phrases used which I don't feel would have been appropriate for that period and place; “Three days, max ...” is an example. Two other small points: Jan's escape by boat was harrowing and for more than just this, I would have liked to have seen a map of this part of Europe in the front of the book to pinpoint some of the places mentioned in the text – my knowledge of Eastern Europe being rather limited. Finally, the cover. Absolutely nothing wrong with design at all, but it is rather dark in colour and although the title in white stands out, the author's name does not.

I bring these points up not because I think it is a poor book, but rather the opposite. It is a good book and I enjoyed it very much as, I believe, will those who have an interest in this little documented aspect of World War II.

© Richard Tearle



click here to return to home page 'Bookshelf' then scroll down for more items of interest

9 June 2018

It is the Weekend 9th June

No reviews over the weekend 
but did you miss...


* * * 

* * *
Have you seen our

where you will find all sorts of interesting things
 to amuse, entertain and inform!


8 June 2018

A Discovering Diamonds review of Disruption by Mary Withall

AMAZON UK £4.99 £12.99
AMAZON US $7.o3 $17.16 
AMAZON CA $8.33

Family Drama
19th Century
New Zealand, Scotland

Although not divided as such, this is a book of three parts. In the beginning we meet James Bantrie, a Scottish minister who is unwilling to meet the changes imposed by the Scottish church – the 'Disruption' of the title. He secures an appointment as minister on a fairly remote Scottish island where nearly all of the few inhabitants are employed in the slate mines. Almost at once he is beset by doubts and guilt that he has taken his family away from a degree of luxury. He and his wife, Judith, befriend a widow, Jessie Dundas, a woman shunned by the islanders, Though she is respectable, she does have a past. We also meet Alexander Beaton, a doctor whose hopes of inheriting his father's practice are dashed when his elder brother returns and is given the honour. Separately, they decide to take up an offer for Scots to settle in New Zealand, Jessie travelling with the Bantrie family. Another good reason for the title.

The second part is the voyage in which a few more characters are introduced and finally we follow their varying fortunes on arrival in their new home, their adjustment to the new conditions and interaction with the native Maoris.

Throughout these three important phases, Ms Withall never flags and holds the reader’s interest at all times. She is not afraid to portray her protagonists as nothing less than normal human beings, none of them infallible, all doing and saying things in common with their personalities and situations as the author develops their characters. Nor is she afraid to kill off a character or two on the way.

This a large book of nearly 500 pages, yet I found it difficult to put down and completed a full reading in just a couple of days.

But ….

The author has been very badly let down by her editors/publisher. There are a number of typos, spelling mistakes and punctuation errors. 'Born' for 'borne' on two occasions, for example. The character of Tobias Leny changes a couple of times to 'Levy' and that of Eleanor Parker switched from 'Nellie' to 'Ellie' and back again.  Although pounds shillings and pence are used regularly, there is one instance of 'thirty shillings and thirty pence' – surely '2s and 6d' to be consistent? These, I feel are not the fault of the writer, but of an editor/proof reader and should have been picked up well before the printing stage. For me they mar an extremely interesting and well-written book. I wholeheartedly suggest a re-edit and reprint - this would have rated a 5* Discovered Diamond without the mistakes.

I don't know whether the author has plans for a sequel, but there is plenty of scope for one as the remaining characters – and the children of course – have plenty of mileage left within them.

All in all, then, a thoroughly enjoyable story, despite the bloopers. It is well-written and the author displays a remarkable knowledge of mining and 'primitive' medical issues. I was also impressed by the diverse characters and their progress.

© Richard Tearle



click here to return to home page 'Bookshelf' then scroll down for more items of interest